
(© Zack Klein/Wikipedia) (© Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call/Getty Images)
By Logan Cohen
This article explores the escalating legal dispute between Radiohead’s lead guitarist, Jonny Greenwood and director Paul Thomas Anderson, against Universal Pictures over the song Barbara Rose being featured in the new and controversial documentary Melania. What begins as a disagreement over a song quickly develops into deeper conflict about artistic control and contractual limitations. This controversy is further centered around the nuances of composer agreements and song licensing agreements, and if the law is able to intervene by way of removing music from released films altogether. By examining the doctrine of specific performance and the practical realities of film distribution, this article explores not only who owns the music, but who ultimately controls it, and with that, whether Greenwood and Anderson have a sufficient claim against Universal for breach of contract.
In 2017, Anderson released the film Phantom Thread in collaboration with Universal Pictures. The film featured a score written by Johnny Greenwood, including a song called Barbara Rose.[1] Following Greenwood and Anderson’s discovery of the use of Barbara Rose in the controversial documentary Melania, a representative for Greenwood spoke with news outlet Variety and shared that the pair had requested the song be removed from the documentary.[2]According to Greenwood and Anderson, Universal, which was responsible for licensing the music to Amazon MGM Studios (“Amazon MGM”) for Melania, breached Greenwood’s composer agreement by failing to consult him on their third-party use of Barbara Rose.[3] Universal owns the copyright for the score of Phantom Thread, which raises a concern of whether Universal is at fault and if Greenwood has the authority to seek removal of Barbara Rose from Melania.[4]
Generally, composer agreements such as the one Greenwood entered into with Universal for his Phantom Thread score differ slightly from the average song licensing agreement.[5] Composer agreements may offer less discretion to artists because they often involve transferring ownership of a song or score in whole or in part.[6] When entering composer agreements, the artists are typically aware that they are relinquishing many of the rights to their score.[7] Greenwood claims that, though he does not hold the copyright to the Phantom Thread score, Universal breached the third-party provision of their composer agreement by not getting consent from Greenwood to use Barbara Rose in Melania.[8] This would depend on whether the third-party provision expressly states that the artist must consent to the material being licensed to a third party.[9] A third-party provision allows a party outside of the composer agreement, often referred to as a “publisher,” the right to license some or all of the musical composition.[10] A 1995 case, Third Story Music, Inc. v. Waits, highlights a similar issue where an artist exercised their discretion in objecting to their music being licensed to a third party.[11] However, in objecting, a secondary issue was raised: whether this artist’s exercise of rights was a breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.[12] Ultimately, the court concluded there was no breach of good faith because both parties entered the composer agreement with the understanding that the artist was permitted to use their discretion in allowing a third-party to license their music.[13] Although it is unclear whether formal legal proceedings have begun among Greenwood, Anderson, and Universal, if litigation does arise, the outcome will likely turn on the language of the third-party consent clause in the composer agreement.[14] If that provision mirrors the Third Story Music agreement, a court will likely find in favor of Greenwood and Anderson for breach of contract, as the licensing of the Phantom Thread score would require the mutual consent of both Greenwood and Universal.[15]
Alternatively, song-licensing agreements allow licensees to use a copyrighted work for a specific purpose without ownership of the work being transferred.[16] These agreements are narrower in scope, which can allow artists to have more power in deciding how and where their works can be used.[17] The U.S. Copyright Act dictates that copyright holders have “exclusive rights to do and to authorize . . . in the case of literary, musical, dramatic, and choreographic works, pantomimes, and pictorial, graphic, or sculptural works, including the individual images of a motion picture or other audiovisual work, to display the copyrighted work publicly”.[18] For Greenwood and Anderson, holding sole copyright to the score of Phantom Thread would have given them slightly more power because they could have individually licensed the film score to Universal for its use just in the film, preventing Universal from licensing that material to a third party, or using it in any other context.[19]
In terms of damages, Greenwood and Anderson are seeking to be remedied through special performance in requesting that the song be removed from the film.[20] Though an award of specific performance in these circumstances is rare, in Tamarind Lithography Workshop v. Sanders,[21] specific performance was granted to remedy the breach of contract, which in this case was failing to give screen credits to the appellants for their contribution to a motion picture. Following the logic of Tamarind, Greenwood and Anderson would have a strong argument in favor of a specific performance remedy because Universal never gave Greenwood the option to consent and thus, breached the contract.[22] The challenge with this remedy to remove Barbara Rose from Melania is that Amazon MGM would likely face an intense financial hit, given they have not broken even through box office sales.[23] It is reported that Amazon MGM spent a combined $75 million dollars on the film and has only earned $10 million dollars through box office sales, which they are hoping to increase through the documentary’s release on Prime Video.[24]
Ultimately, Greenwood and Anderson have a valid claim against Universal. Universal’s failure to consult with Greenwood has opened the gate for what could be a major lawsuit that will undoubtedly add to the existing financial burden Amazon MGM has already experienced following the release of the film. Though Universal could throw money at Greenwood, Anderson, and Amazon MGM, specific performance of removing the song from the documentary entirely would fully restore the breach of contract on their end and satisfy the burdened parties. Though the exact details of Greenwood and Universal’s third-party provision are unknown, if there is an emphasis on consent from the artist to license the song or score for other uses as Greenwood claims, Universal ought to have known that, by licensing the song for a highly controversial documentary, legal dilemmas would arise. The burden was on Universal to ask for consent, and in failing to do so, they opened the floodgates to a major legal battle.
Student Biography:
This blog was written by Logan Cohen (logan.cohen@su.suffolk.edu), a 2L at Suffolk University Law School. Logan is currently a legal intern with Volunteer Lawyers for the Arts of Massachusetts and Connecticut, as well as the Alumni Affairs Chief of Operations for the Student Bar Association and Events Coordinator for the Child and Family Law Association. In her spare time, Logan plays guitar and piano and loves to see musicals and travel as often as possible.
Disclaimer: The Suffolk Law Sports & Entertainment Law Association Blog is a student-run publication intended to encourage discussion, analysis, and enjoyment of issues related to sports and entertainment law. The content published on the Blog is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. The views and opinions expressed are those of the individual author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Suffolk University Law School, the Sports & Entertainment Law Association, or any affiliated faculty, staff, or students. Nothing on this Blog should be construed as creating an attorney
[1] See Lindsay Kornick, Radiohead founder demands song be removed from ‘Melania’ documentary, https://nypost.com/2026/02/10/media/radiohead-founder-demands-song-be-removed-from-melania-documentary/ (last visited Feb 20, 2026).
[2] See Jem Aswad & Rebecca Rubin, Paul Thomas Anderson and Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood Want ‘Melania’ Doc to Remove ‘Phantom Thread’ Music: Its Use Is a ‘Breach of Composer Agreement’, variety, https://variety.com/2026/film/news/melania-anderson-greenwood-want-phantom-thread-music-removed-1236656857/ (last visited Feb. 20, 2026).
[3] Id.
[4] Id.
[5] See Lionel S. Sobel, Soundtrack Music, 9 Entertainment Industry ¶184A.02 (Doug Nevin ed., LexisNexis 2025).
[6] See Brown v. Goldstein, 34 Cal. App. 5th 418, 425 (Cal. App. 2d 2019).
[7] Id.
[8] See Kornick, supra note 1.
[9] See Third Story Music, Inc. v. Waits, 41 Cal. App. 4th 798, 804 (Cal. App. 2d 1995).
[10] See 6 Melville B. Nimmer & David Nimmer, Nimmer on Copyright § 30.01 (Matthew Bender, Rev. Ed. 2025).
[11] See Third Story Music, 41 Cal. App.4th at 804.
[12] Id.
[13] Id.
[14] Id.
[15] Id.
[16] See Preston v. State Bd. of Equalization, 25 Cal. 4th 197, 215 (2001).
[17] Id.
[18] See 17 U.S.C. § 106 (5).
[19] Id.
[20] See Kornick, supra note 1.
[21] 143 Cal. App. 3d 571 (Cal. App. 2d 1983).
[22] Id.
[23] See Kornick, supra note 1.
[24] Id.
Leave a Reply