
By Brenner Morton
A tennis player can now collect a substantial check at the US Open and still arrive on a college campus eligible to compete. Win that same check after enrolling, and NCAA rules still limit what the player may accept to actual and necessary expenses. The difference is a date on an enrollment record, not the level of competition or the source of the prize money. In April of 2026, the NCAA agreed to a $2.02 million settlement in the case Brantmeier v. NCAA.
Reese Brantmeier helped change the first half of that equation.[1] At the 2021 US Open, while still in high school, she earned $48,913.[2] Under the NCAA’s old Division I tennis rules, she could keep $10,000 in prize money for the calendar year, plus permitted expenses, without jeopardizing her college eligibility.[3] A dispute over her claimed expenses subsequently kept her out of University of North Carolina’s fall 2022 season.[4] She sued the NCAA in 2024, with former Texas player Maya Joint later joining the case.[5]
Joint faced an even larger choice.[6] She earned $147,000 reaching the second round of the 2024 US Open before entering Texas but could not keep most of it under the old rule if she wanted to play college tennis.[7] She later turned professional.[8]
Their class action argued that the NCAA’s prize money restrictions unlawfully limited compensation for athletic performance.[9] The NCAA alternatively denied that its rules violated antitrust law.[10] In April 2026, the organization changed its Division I pre-enrollment policy: prospective athletes in all sports may now accept prize money without losing eligibility on that basis.[11] The proposed settlement also sets aside $2 million for eligible Division I tennis players who forfeited winnings.[12] The court has scheduled a fairness hearing for January 8, 2027.[13]
For Brantmeier, the lawsuit was an uncomfortable way to defend a sport she loves.[14] When I spoke with her in Newport in July 2026, I asked how it felt to lead the effort for change.[15]
“It’s scary, suing an organization like the NCAA is a big deal, and it can be intimidating when it’s Brantmeier versus the NCAA,” she said.[16] “It’s me sticking my neck out.”[17]
She was just as quick to describe what college tennis had meant to her.[18] “The NCAA was part of a chapter of my life that I cherish.”[19] “I love college tennis, and I was proud to be part of it.”[20] “But I can separate that from recognizing that certain rules need to change because they aren’t serving the players.”[21]
Her argument reflects a tension in the current college sports economy.[22] Athletes may earn money from their name, image and likeness, and participating Division I schools may make direct payments to athletes, yet the NCAA still regulates what an enrolled tennis player can keep from a tournament played outside college competition.[23] “In the NIL era, it doesn’t make sense that we can’t earn prize money while other athletes are earning millions from their name, image and likeness,” Brantmeier reflected.[24]
The distinction matters because the settlement’s broad headline can obscure its narrower rule change.[25] Although the lawsuit addressed the NCAA’s limits on both prospective and enrolled Division I tennis players, the NCAA expressly said that its April change left the post-enrollment prize money rules intact.[26] Under the current Division I rule, an enrolled player may accept prize money based on performance in an outside event only up to actual and necessary expenses, and the money must come from the event sponsor.[27]
A tournament’s prize money is based on how far a player advances, while the NCAA’s limit is tied to what that player spent to compete.[28] A deep run can therefore create an unusual result: the better the player performs, the more winnings they may have to decline to remain eligible.[29] The rule allows college players to enter outside events and earn prize money toward their expenses, but it still prevents them from keeping the full reward for a breakthrough week when their winnings exceed that limit.[30]
Consider another UNC player, Fiona Crawley.[31] She qualified for the 2023 US Open in singles and doubles while already in college.[32] Her university reported that she had to turn down most of her $81,000 in winnings to preserve her eligibility.[33] Brantmeier’s victory would have changed the calculation for a player who earned that money before enrolling.[34] Yet, it did not erase the limit Crawley encountered after enrollment.[35]
One possible justification is that enrollment marks a change in an athlete’s relationship with college competition.[36] But that leaves a difficult distinction to explain in tennis, where players can move between college matches and professional events.[37] Why should a US Open result count differently for eligibility depending on whether it comes just before or just after a player starts school?[38]
There may be a rationale for distinguishing a prospect from someone on a college roster, but these examples raise a central question: why does accepting prize money above expenses threaten eligibility only after a player becomes a student-athlete?[39] The athlete still won the match.[40] The tournament, not the school, still supplied the purse.[41]
Brantmeier told me that seeing the rule’s effects on other players made her decision feel necessary, even if another athlete might eventually have taken on the challenge.[42] “The sooner we see change, the better, and I’m happy to take that on.”[43] Her case delivered a meaningful change for players coming to college.[44] The line at enrollment remains the next part of the story.[45]
The court is likely to approve the proposed settlement because it provides compensation for eligible players who forfeited winnings and secures a change to the pre-enrollment rules without the expense, delay or uncertainty of further litigation. Those benefits support approval under Rule 23, which requires a class settlement to be fair, reasonable and adequate, although the court must also evaluate the distribution of relief, attorneys’ fees, and treatment of class members. Approval would secure an important victory for Brantmeier and future college players, while leaving the post enrollment expense limit intact. The likely outcome is therefore a meaningful reform that leaves college tennis facing the question at the center of this case: why should enrollment change how much of a tournament’s prize money a player can keep?
Student Biography:
Brenner Morton is a 2L at Suffolk University Law School and serves as an Executive Board Advisor for the Sports and Entertainment Law Association (SELA). His interests include sports law, athlete representation, and the analysis of professional tennis. He is the founder of SimonSaysTennis, where he covers professional tennis through match analysis, interviews, and industry commentary.
Contact: Brenner.morton@su.suffolk.edu
Disclaimer:
Disclaimer: The Suffolk Law Sports & Entertainment Law Association Blog is a student-run publication intended to encourage discussion, analysis, and enjoyment of issues related to sports and entertainment law. The content published on the Blog is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. The views and opinions expressed are those of the individual author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Suffolk University Law School, the Sports & Entertainment Law Association, or any affiliated faculty, staff, or students. Nothing on this Blog should be construed as creating an attorney–client relationship.
[1] See NCAA Staff, DI Cabinet Adopts Changes to Eligibility Rules for Prospects, NCAA (Apr. 15, 2026), https://www.ncaa.org/news/media-center-di-cabinet-adopts-changes-to-eligibility-rules-for-prospects/ (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) [hereinafter Eligibility Update]. See also Brantmeier v. NCAA M.D.N.C No. 1:24-CV-238 (2025)
[2] See TENNIS.com, NCAA Changing Prize Money Rules in $2.02M Settlement for Lawsuit Led by Brantmeier and Joint, TENNIS.com (Apr. 29, 2026), https://www.tennis.com/news/articles/ncaa-changes-prize-money-rules-2-million-lawsuit-reese-brantmeier-maya-joint (last visited Oct. 24, 2026).
[3] See NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, Athletics Eligibility—Prize Money or Payment Based on Performance, Draft and Inquiry and Use of Agents—Before Initial, Full-Time Collegiate Enrollment, NCAA Legis. Serv. Database, https://web3.ncaa.org/lsdbi/search/proposalView?id=109227 (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) (reproducing former Bylaws 12.1.2.4.2.1 and 12.1.2.4.2.2).
[4] See TENNIS.com, supra note 2.
[5] See Brian Murphy, NCAA Agrees to Change Prize Money Rules, Pay $2M Settlement in Case Brought by UNC Tennis Star, WRAL News (Apr. 29, 2026), https://www.wral.com/sports/north-carolina-reese-brantmeier-proposed-settlement-with-ncaa-april-2026/ (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) (identifying the initial March 2024 complaint and the two named plaintiffs).
[6] See TENNIS.com, supra note 2 (reporting both players’ winnings; comparison by the author).
[7] Id.
[8] Id.
[9] NCAA Tennis Prize Money Class Action, Brantmeier et al. v. NCAA, No. 1:24-cv-00238 (M.D.N.C.), Settlement Adm’r, https://www.ncaatennisprizemoneyclassaction.com/ (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) [hereinafter Settlement Notice] (answering the question: “What Is This Lawsuit About?”).
[10] Id.
[11] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1. See also NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, pt. A (applying the amendment to athletes initially enrolling full time on or after August 1, 2026).
[12] See Settlement Notice, supra note 9 (“Who Is Included in the Settlement?” and “What Does the Settlement Provide?”).
[13] Id.
[14] Author’s analysis based on Brenner Morton, Interview with Reese Brantmeier, Newport Hall of Fame Open, Newport, Rhode Island, SimonSaysTennis (July 2026), https://simonsaystennis.com/reese-brantmeier-on-her-transition-to-the-wta-tour/ (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) [hereinafter Newport Interview] (describing her account of the intimidation involved and her affection for college tennis).
[15] Id. (interview date and question supplied by the author).
[16] Id.
[17] Id.
[18] Id.
[19] See Newport Interview, supra note 14.
[20] Id.
[21] Id.
[22] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1. See also Newport Interview, supra note 14 (tension identified by the author).
[23] See NCAA Staff, A Letter from NCAA President Charlie Baker, NCAA (June 6, 2025), https://www.ncaa.org/news/media-center-a-letter-from-ncaa-president-charlie-baker/ (last visited Oct. 24, 2026) [hereinafter Baker Letter]. See also NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, Bylaw 12.1.2.4.2 (post-enrollment prize money).
[24] See Newport Interview, supra note 14.
[25] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1.
[26] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1. See also Settlement Notice, supra note 9 (“Who Is Included in the Settlement?”).
[27] See NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, Bylaw 12.1.2.4.2 (“After Initial, Full-Time Collegiate Enrollment”).
[28] Id.
[29] Id.
[30] Id.
[31] See Michael Koh, UNC’s Reese Brantmeier Settles NCAA Lawsuit, Lifting Prize Money Restrictions, Chapelboro (Apr. 30, 2026), https://chapelboro.com/sports/uncs-reese-brantmeier-settles-ncaa-lawsuit-lifting-prize-money-restrictions (last visited Oct. 24, 2026).
[32] Id.
[33] Id.
[34] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1.
[35] Id.
[36] Id.
[37] See Koh, supra note 32.
[38] See NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, Bylaws 12.1.2.4.1–.2. See also Eligibility Update, supra note 1
[39] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1.
[40] See NCAA, Division I Proposal No. 2026-32, Bylaw 12.1.2.4.2
[41] Id.
[42] See Newport Interview, supra note 14.
[43] Id.
[44] See Eligibility Update, supra note 1.
[45] Id.
Leave a Reply